Authors
Book Titles Home
The Honor of the Queen by David Weber

Military science fiction is primarily known for male lead characters oozing
testosterone who pull off amazing victories despite overwhelming odds. If this
is what you are looking for, skip the Honor Harrington series of books. However,
if you are looking for a fresh perspective on military sci-fi with a believable
female commander, pull up a chair and settle in.
The Kingdom of Manticore and the Republic of Haven have been at odds for
years. Everyone on both sides knows that war is inevitable. However, to date,
conflicts between the two sides have been restricted to clandestine, strategic
thrusts in out of the way places. Both sides are seeking allies for the coming
war and the planets Grayson and Masada occupy an essential location between the
two empires.
Grayson and Masada have been isolated from other human settlements for
centuries. Their cultures are based on old religious beliefs stemming from the
original biblical tales on Earth. On both planets, women are second class (maybe
even third class) citizens with no rights or privileges. Worse, the citizens of
Masada are hard core zealots who hate the Graysons and believe they are
blasphemers against the faith. Masada has previously tried to conquer Grayson
without success.
Enter Honor Harrington, one of the Maticorian’s most promising young
commanders. Her mission is to support a diplomatic mission to Grayson to secure
a treaty allowing the installation of a forward military base in their star
system. It would be bad enough if all she had to contend with were fanatical
Masadeans and their secret allies from the Republic of Haven. But Honor must
also contend with the contemptuous attitude of the Grayson military and
political leaders who clearly think Honor should be barefoot, pregnant and in
the kitchen cooking dinner… not anywhere near the bridge of a starship. Will
having enemies on both sides be too much even for Honor to handle?
This is the second book in the Honor Harrington series (I have not yet read
the first volume, On Basilisk Station). Weber does an excellent job of
creating a complex female character in a genre where males tend to dominate. The
six-limbed treecat (a pet that can sense human feelings) that perches on her
shoulders is a nice touch. Weber gets you to empathize with Honor over the
almost impossible situation that she is thrust into. It is never made clear why
a female commander was assigned to this mission when a male would be the obvious
choice, but that didn’t detract from my enjoyment of the story.
The character development of Honor and the other main characters is
sufficient to keep the military action from overwhelming the rest of the story.
Warring religious factions make an interesting backdrop for a strategic military
struggle and the battles are well thought out and choreographed. There are no
miraculous victories here…just hard won battles where the best strategist
wins. One of the few faults of the novel is a lack of explanation of the weapons
and propulsion technology. Although I eventually figured out how things worked
in this universe, some detailed explanation would have been helpful. Perhaps it
was in the first book.
This series now comprises about ten books and is extremely popular. With a
likable, interesting main character and engaging military action, it is easy to
see why this series is popular. I will definitely be reading additional books in
the series.
Reviewed by Alan
Authors Book
Titles Home Top
The Short Victorious
War by David Weber
The third installment in the Honor Harrington series finds our heroine
recovered from the grievous wounds suffered in the battle over Grayson. Assigned
to a new starship that is the pride of the fleet and the envy of every other
captain in the Manticorian navy, Honor has her work cut out for her. Aside from
confronting two old enemies, training a raw crew that has never fought together
before and dealing with mysterious animosity from the Admiral; she has nothing
much to worry about! Oh, of course there is always the threat of war from the
People’s Republic of Haven (the Peeps). Nevertheless, it is all in a day’s
work for Honor!
The Peeps need a war with the Manticorian alliance to divert attention from
their internal strife. The Peep navy outweighs the Manticorian navy by a margin
of almost two to one. It seems like a perfect time to lure Manticore into
starting a war and crushing them quickly. However, the Manticorians have
superior technology on their side as well as brilliant military strategists like
Honor Harrington. Despite the wishes of the Peep government, this war is going
to be anything but short and victorious if the Manticorians have their say!
Unfortunately, this book falls short of its predecessor, The Honor of the
Queen. This is primarily due to an attempt by Weber to cover too much
ground. He appears uncertain whether this book should be about:
- Honor’s military career
- Honor’s love life
- Honor’s struggle with old enemies and demons from her past
- A military conflict between Manticore and the Peeps
- An exploration of the downfall of the Peep economy
Weber attempts to cover it all and the result is that all the plot lines are
shortchanged. The enemies that emerge from Honor’s past are menacing, but
Weber does not do enough with them to build any tension. Honor’s relationship
with another officer is a mere aside as opposed to being serious plot
development. In addition, since so much of the book is devoted to the other plot
lines, the military conflict comes off as flat and lacking tension. The
brightest spots are the pages devoted to the Peep’s economy. Most of their
citizens are on the dole and constantly agitate for increases in the monthly
stipend checks from the government. Therefore, the rulers must constantly expand
the empire and bleed conquered systems dry to keep the proletariats at home
satisfied.
I am going to continue reading this series because the other books in it have
interesting topics and I believe this volume was really a set-up for future
volumes. Let us see what tight spots Honor can get out of next time!
Reviewed by Alan
Authors Book
Titles Home Top
Field of Dishonor
by David Weber 
Buy This Book Hardcover
Paperback
The fourth installment in the Honor Harrington series is a departure from the
previous volumes. Instead of focusing on military engagements, a political
crisis during peacetime is explored. Naturally, Honor is at the center of it.
After the uprising within the government of the People’s Republic of Haven,
their war against the Manticorian alliance ceases. The Peeps' new government is
busy purging their military of "undesirable" officers. The resulting
turmoil among the Havenites is a perfect opportunity for the Manticorian
alliance to declare war on the Peeps and take the offensive. However, a power
struggle breaks out in the Manticorian parliament, led by an old enemy of Honor
Harrington's. Suddenly, Honor must do battle on the treacherous field of politics,
not in the vacuum of space where she was trained. However, one false move on the
political battlefield could just as easily result in her death.
This volume is a vast improvement over The Short Victorious War. Weber
invests a lot of time in the character development of Honor, her lover and her
closest associate. We know in subsequent volumes that Weber will probably get
back to military engagements, but this one is a refreshing change. Although the
story was a bit predictable, I still found it held my attention up to the end.
Honor is portrayed in a more human light (as opposed to being deified in earlier
volumes) and this made me like her character even more than I already did. Weber
has a good franchise going here which shows no signs of stopping (about 11
volumes in the series now). I’m hooked enough to read volume 5.
Reviewed by Alan
Authors Book
Titles Home Top